Transparency in Wage Structures Act: Companies Receive Fewer Requests than Expected
• Pay gap—14% of inquirers earn below average
• 85% of HR managers do not believe that the Transparency in Wage Structures Act will have implications for the future
Cologne, June 6, 2018
Employees still reticent about making requests
“Requests in German companies are still contained, and so far only a small number of employees have made use of the right to request information. In those organizations where requests have been made, around two are received every month,” explains Neele Siemer, Compensation Expert at Kienbaum, adding, “In a fifth of companies surveyed, the ratio between female and male inquirers was even. Around 46% of participants in the survey reported fewer requests than expected, and only a very small number of organizations received more requests than expected, with an average of 20 requests per company.
No pay gap identified in 65% of cases
More than 65% of those surveyed indicated that no pay gap had been identified. 14% of those companies who had already responded to requests found that the employees requesting information were generally receiving below-average pay in the comparison group.
Responsibility for responding to requests for information rests with the works council, but employers can take on the responsibility themselves. Neele Siemer says, “In our sample, 18% left responsibility to the works council, but where the works council is responsible for responding, the company receives fewer requests. In these organizations, only four requests on average had been received, compared to twice that number where the employer was responsible, or was planning to be.”
Participants skeptical about effects on pay for female employees
According to the study, the greatest challenges when it came to responding to requests for information, were calculating comparative pay and assessing the comparison group. Although 80% of those surveyed said it posed a challenge to justify the pay gap, 55% provided justification in addition to their response. Only 13% percent said that they had no difficulties in responding.
“The results indicate that it will be very interesting to see how companies will handle implementation of the Transparency in Wage Structures Act in the future. We will continue to monitor changes within those companies through the year,” says Neele Siemer. “But it’s also rather doubtful that the Act will actually support its original intention, i.e. reducing the pay gap between men and women. 85% of those we surveyed did not believe that the Act would have implications on pay for female employees.”
The Kienbaum Compensation Portal online application offers exclusive 24/7 access to Kienbaum compensation data of the highest standards of quality. This includes access to the Board Remuneration Analyser, an online tool for analysis of board compensation (in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, and other European countries), with individual selection by criteria including company name, industry, and company size. Please note: your data are secure with us; the Compensation Portal is the only TÜV-certified online database of compensation data in Germany. www.kienbaum-compensation-portal.com
Kerstin Wandt – T.: +49 221 801 72-689 | E-Mail: Kerstin.Wandt@kienbaum.de